Your team members will leave. Here’s how to talk to them about it.
And here’s why you can’t steer conversations on buyouts, outside offers, or roles on other teams.

On October 26, Microsoft offered a time-limited voluntary exit package to employees at certain role levels across participating teams in the US, Canada, the UK, and India, available to roughly 60,000 people (by most reports). Almost everything written since has been for the people deciding.
This is written for the person / people sitting across the table from them.
Because somewhere this month, a manager is going to hear a version of a question in a 1:1, a closed-door chat, or a Slack ping that just says “hey, do you have a minute?” (if your heart rate just spiked, I wrote an article recently called “Hey, Do You Have a Minute?” that is for answering any variety of topic on the other side of that question). Today’s article is a super-specific version.
It might be about a buyout package, an outside offer, or a role on another team. The question underneath is always the same:
“Should I take it?”
And it’s not actually the manager’s question to decide, but managers have a much bigger part to play in what happens next than you might think.
🆘 The first time it was my team
About a month into one of my assignments as a first-line manager, an engineer on my team asked if we could talk.
They’d received an outside offer, and they were strongly considering it.
Before I could say anything, they started to reassure me. They’d been interviewing with outside companies for about six months, well before I arrived, and they didn’t want me to think they were considering leaving because of me.
That was kind of them. It was also helpful, because I was still very much getting to know the team and they were still getting to know me.
But I still felt surprised and shocked. Totally normal, but can be reallllllly distracting if we aren’t intentional about managing it.
I’d talked through stay-or-go decisions plenty of times before: with mentees, with people on adjacent teams, with my own colleagues.
This was the first time it was someone on my team, where I was the one responsible for whatever happened next. It turns out that’s a completely different conversation.
I didn’t have a plan yet, so I did two things.
I thanked them for telling me.
Then I asked whether this was something they wanted to talk about right now, or whether they’d rather schedule time later. I also offered to include our senior manager, who had known them longer than I had and had a great rapport with them.
They chose to schedule time with both of us. Which gave me a little room to breathe.
🛑 Why you (as a manager) can’t steer this conversation
Shortest answer: you aren’t a neutral participant.
Depending on your ✨vibes✨ (and your personal experience / history), a direct report considering leaving can set off a whole chain reaction of feelings: defensiveness, panic, even something that feels a lot like abandonment.
Those feelings are real. They also usually have very little to do with the employee and a lot more to do with the environment you’re in and your own background.
That’s why the two most natural responses both usually backfire.
❌ “Stay, we need you.”
This feels supportive, but it puts your needs at the center of their decision. It’s an ultimatum in disguise and long term, an ultimatum erodes trust.
❌ “Sure, you should go for it.”
This feels generous, but it’s still you making the call for them (and it can land as “we won’t fight for you”).
Both of these reactions are versions of steering the conversation that ultimately won’t help the employee (or you) move forward in a constructive way.
The job in this conversation is to help them think clearly about their decision, and to keep your own fears from doing the talking.
😮💨 Put your own mask on first
Before I walked into that meeting, I needed to navigate my own emotions and reaction, some of which were coming from a place of feeling like I didn’t feel prepared to even have the conversation yet.
A few things I did (and that I’d recommend doing) included:
I refreshed myself on what options were actually possible. I was generally familiar with how promotions, compensation changes, and counter offers worked where I was (I’d been through most of them at least once), but I re-read the processes anyway and got a quick call in with my HR partner to ask questions. Knowing the options made the unknowns a lot less anxiety inducing.
I huddled with my senior manager before the meeting. We agreed ahead of time on how we’d approach it: with as much curiosity and openness as we could, not with the intent to influence the outcome. If the employee wanted to talk about options like a counter offer, we’d share whatever information we could. But we weren’t going in to make a pitch.
Walking in with a plan is what made me feel more calm.
💡The questions that actually helped
Here are a few questions worth asking in these conversations that can help keep the focus on the team member and their needs:
“How are you feeling as you consider this offer?”
“What decision criteria do you have in mind? Which ones are you feeling strongest about?”
“Who is supporting you (outside of work) while you make this decision?”
“Where do you see each of these paths leading? Does this opportunity bring you closer to your career goals, or further away?”
That last question wasn’t a sneaky way to argue for staying.
It was simply a way to help them get clearer on whether this opportunity brought them closer to what they wanted.
At one point, the employee asked us directly how we would rank their criteria: location, remote flexibility, schedule, salary, the full compensation package, career trajectory. It was a fair question! And it was exactly the moment where it would have been easiest to steer.
Instead, we turned it back to them: which of those were they feeling strongest about? That’s probably the best place to start.
On the support question, we knew they had family to lean on. We also offered to set up time with our HR partner if it would help to compare compensation, insurance, and benefits side by side.
Making that space was a way to help without weighing in.
The conversation ended up being really helpful. They told us about some of what they were weighing, and also a few things that would matter if they were to seriously consider staying.
We did end up putting together a counter offer with our HR team. (The full story of how that went, and what I’ve learned since about counter offers and ultimatums, is coming in a few weeks for paid subscribers.)
Ultimately, they decided to take the outside offer, which was the right decision for them at that time (given everything we had talked about).
💬 If they go: let them tell their own story
A few things I learned as we worked through knowledge transfer in this scenario (and in related instances since then):
First, they got to frame their own departure. Somewhere along the way we started calling their move a “study abroad”.
A few years outside, gaining experience somewhere else. That language turned out to be a gift. It gave them a way to tell the team they were leaving that felt like an adventure, not an escape, and it kept the door open in everyone’s minds (including theirs).
Second, we sorted out their remaining work together. We went through their projects and decided which ones would pass along to someone else and which would go into our backlog until we could review them or find the right person to pick them back up. Not glamorous. Very necessary.
For more on how to manage a backlog, check out “You Don’t Need to be a Unicorn Manager”.
You Don’t Need to Be a ‘Unicorn’ Manager
I was sitting across from one of my direct reports in a 1:1 (a manager I was actively working to develop) trying to explain what I meant when I said I wanted to see a stable operational foundation for their team.
💫 What “good” looks like, even when they leave
Here’s the part I didn’t expect. Going through all of this brought me and the team member a lot closer. By their last few days, we were talking with real warmth about a future where they might come back, and I made it clear I was happy to stay connected while they were out in the industry.
And several years later, they reached out to me and a few other people they’d kept in touch with. They were interested in coming back.
And they did.
We’re on different teams now and I’ve moved along in my own leadership journey, but it’s always fun to see them. We’ve kept a good rapport.
You can’t control whether someone stays. You can control whether they’d want to work together again.
I’d love to hear from you: has someone on your team ever asked you a version of “should I take it?” What did you say? Leave a comment, find me on Notes, or send me a message. I read everything.
See you next Tuesday,




Discussion about this post